Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Taking the easy route

I am guilty of optimism, probably over-optimism, as this article proved. It does keep me grounded to reality, that while certain figures look good on the blackboard, they may not convey the real picture. And the real picture is....
  • The poor do not get justice, the Nithari killings just prove that point. And yes, most of the country carried on with their daily activities once the initial debate was over. The Nithari killings are just the tip of the iceberg, convicting the murderers does not solve the underlying problems with our judicial system. Every citizen of the country, rich or poor, has a right to justice. Do we provide it? No. Guilty!
  • Our children's right to education. All the developed countries and a few developing countries, mandate free and compulsory education for their children for a minimum number of years(UK-12, China-9, Venezuela - 9, Germany -10, Sweden -9). Our constitution too had mandated compulsory education for every child up to the age of 14, which had to be achieved by 1960. But successive governments have failed to uphold their constitutional responsibilities, and coupled with poor population planning, securing this right for our children remains a distant dream. Around 50% of our country's children-of- schooling-age are out of school. Have we failed them? Yes. Guilty on second count!
  • Poverty. 30% of our people live below the poverty line, as per the World Bank, that's every individual who earns less than a dollar a day. An offshoot, India has more undernourished children than Africa. Since Africa's plight gets more attention on global media and the failure of Indian media to highlight this statistic, it largely goes unnoticed. Is the rest of the country to blame? Yes. Guilty again!
The well-to-do remain mostly numbed when faced with the plights of the poor. Pictures of poverty, uncommon deaths are no longer new to us, and doesn't evince the sympathy it ideally should.We cannot ignore the plights of large sections of our populace, in our rush to view India as an increasingly successful nation. Those marginalised cannot and should not be marginalised further, as we plod ahead. A nation is not built by governments, armies or bureaucrats, the fabric of a nation is it's people, a people tightly woven together. It is our responsibility to alleviate the the conditions of the underprivileged, it is our responsibility to bring the lower sections of our society on par with the rest of the nation.

As much as we fail to realize it, each one of us is indebted to the nation, indebted to our countrymen/women, an exposition of which I shall reserve for my next blog.

3 comments:

Kaushik said...

Yes whatever you are trying to convey in this blog is right. I appreciate your understanding of the situation. But 50 -60% of the Indian so-called educated and elite population is aware of this problem and what is it doing about this? For that matter what are you doing to improve the situation? I don't see any solution in is this blog. I am sure most of them who read this blog are aware of these problems. But what's the point?

Neel said...

Kaushik, I could give easy solutions such as -
* provide better education
* provide employment
but they would be vague and would remain at a very high level. We all know the challenge lies in execution.
The solution to these problems will not lie hidden in words of a blog, the solution lies in actual action on the ground. The idea of this blog is to force people like you into action, to foster a debate between those interested in the development of the country. Hope that clarifies.

Thottekat K M said...

Neel: Firstly, I'd like to point out that the poverty figure quoted here (30%) is that of people living under extreme poverty in the least developed nations as defined by the World Bank, i.e. <$1 a day... For middle economies the poverty level defined is <$2 a day... The figure then comes up to an astonishing 75% of the population...

Kaushik: What goes on generally is intellectual talk by a small minority of the "elite"... However, this is generally ineffectual as the talk is between those who are already aware of the situation... And it's not 50-60% of the educated, but 95-100% of those who are aware of the problem... However, most of them prefer to dismiss these thoughts... They live under a delusion that as urban India (& the middle class) grows (through liberalisation and globalisation), rural India (& the poor) will too... The others, while realising the problem, prefer to set it aside thinking that the problem is not one that can be resolved easily, and certainly not by them...

Neel is attempting to rally together Indians through plain (and hard) facts... While the result of this will not be immediately apparent, it makes people think...

Neel may not be able to get a solution to your questions (& these are not simple questions), but perhaps someone else reading his blog will...

At least, let's hope someone will...